The kTome of Pansophic Wisdom
This website is dedicated to all wiseacres out there - you’re welcome to f*ck the rules

Main


   
Term Cannot
Rules Text
Errata (v3.8) The Word “Cannot”
If an effect has the word “cannot” in its description, then it is an absolute: That effect may not be overridden by other effects. For example, if Wildfire Assault is played, which has an effect that kills characters and “cannot be saved,” then a card like Kiss of Life that saves that character would not work. Also note that if a card cannot be saved, a player cannot even attempt to save it with a saving card or effect.
Note, however, that Wildfire Assault may still be canceled, unless it has the text “cannot be canceled.” A character that cannot be killed/saved/etc. may not be chosen for that effect.
For example, the House Florent Knight, which has the text “House Florent Knight cannot be discarded from play by any card effect,” could not be chosen by the controlling player as the target of a card like Marched to the Wall, which discards a card from play; however, the House Florent Knight will not be affected if it is the only character in play.
Related Cards Ser Davos Seaworth
   
     
Questions:
   
Asked: 05.11.2005 - 16:41:22 Uhr
Answered: 18.11.2005 - 01:39:11 Uhr
   
Question: Assume my opponent has 2 Dragons in play that cannot be killed in addition to 3 other characters and then plays Wildfire Assault. Do all of his characters survive?
   
Answer: The important thing in dealing with Cannot Be Killed (CBK hereon) is to remember the following two things:
1: A character with CBK cannot be chosen to be killed. This means that said character cannot be chosen as the target of a kill effect (i.e. Swing the Sword, Harrenhal), and cannot be chosen to die for Military Claim. Nor can a CBK character be chosen as your victim for Deadly.*

This relates to your Wildfire situation due to the following: Wildfire asks that you choose (up to) three characters to NOT be killed. In no guise are you chosing characters to die: you are chosing characters to survive. Thus, the dragons do not have to be chosen as survivors for Wildfire assault (and you aren't chosing them to die, thereby bypassing the "don't chose to kill" part of #1).

2: If a kill effect would attempt to initiate on a CBK character (and this is now ANY CBK character), that kill effect has no effect. This "no effect" result is not a cancel, nor is it a save. The kill effect just doesn't work.

Examples of when this can occur include Winter is Here, We Take It All!, Crushed at the Walls, and Wildfire Assault.

This relates to the Wildfire situation because the Dragons not chosen are suppossed to be killed. However, their CBK text indicates that the kill has no effect. Therefore, the Wildfire will try to kill them and fail, leaving them alive, as well as the three characters you chose to survive.
Author: SilentSword
Source: http://www.fantasyflightgames.com
Rules: Winter Edition
FAQ: v4.0
 
Edit/correct/amend this answer ...

   
Asked: 05.11.2005 - 16:43:39 Uhr
Answered: 05.11.2005 - 16:44:11 Uhr
   
Question: Can a character that cannot be killed be saved before his ability kicks in, though it wouldn’t be necessary?
   
Answer: No. Cannot always means "don’t even try", and in order to save somebody from being killed he has to be chosen for being killed.
Author: Zoood!
Source: http://www.fantasyflightgames.com
Rules: Valyrian Edition
FAQ: v3.14
 
Edit/correct/amend this answer ...

   
Asked: 20.12.2005 - 03:02:15 Uhr
Answered: 21.12.2005 - 01:44:22 Uhr
   
Question: On the last tourney, we had a little disagreement about characters that cannot be killed and disintegration. One player argued that cards like Blood Magic could not be played on a character that cannot be killed because it is no legal target. I argued that the character cannot be killed, but suffers the -X STR though. Who's right?
   
Answer: Since "lower STR, kill if 0" has two separate effects, CBK characters can be targets of the "lower STR" effect, even though they normally could not be targets of "kill" effects.

So you are right. You can use Blood Magic on a CBK character and it gets the -X STR. However, it will not die, even if the STR becomes 0.
Author: ktom5
Source:
Rules: Winter Edition
FAQ: v4.0
 
Edit/correct/amend this answer ...

   
Asked: 11.12.2006 - 08:43:41 Uhr
Answered: 11.12.2006 - 14:04:38 Uhr
   
Question: I know that it was asked many times, but on Tzumainn it is too chaotic.
Ser Davos Seaworth (VAL) "Cannot be killed" - means don't even try to kill him. Am I right?
Cannot be killed means - Cannot be chosen to be killed.
   
Answer: Correct. "Cannot be killed" means you cannot choose him to be killed.

The confusion comes from the fact that at one time, Ser Davos had specific errata that ALLOWED him (and only him) to be chosen. But that's gone now.
Author: ktom5
Source:
Rules: Iron Throne Edition
FAQ: v4.2
 
Edit/correct/amend this answer ...

   
Asked: 28.09.2009 - 05:24:29 Uhr
   
Question: rZ2R2w tujwgjjrguuy, [url=http://uwqjymwupllv.com/]uwqjymwupllv[/url], [link=http://qldympiuovem.com/]qldympiuovem[/link], http://izucadodirdq.com/
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 11.10.2009 - 15:09:18 Uhr
   
Question: Still pricing is not the only reason why you should buy consolidator airfares for your travel. ambien 381058 amoxicillin vhqs prozac 840 cialis 761018 doxycycline ngi prednisone znji
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 11.10.2009 - 21:34:50 Uhr
   
Question: There are so many advantages to memory foam mattresses over a conventional mattress! soma %-( levitra wnlgbb cialis %-(( tramadol %P ativan 8-D carisoprodol :[
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 12.10.2009 - 00:19:00 Uhr
   
Question: Love brings out the artistic nature in people and stimulates minds to the limit. nexium fygf prozac 1248 tramadol bdo carisoprodol 9629 diflucan jnw meridia =-P
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 22.10.2009 - 23:41:01 Uhr
   
Question: In the Wise Woman tradition there are no diseases and no cures for diseases. life quotes =[[ homeowners insurance tyi
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 09.12.2009 - 17:09:05 Uhr
   
Question: Certain habits health conditions and addictions have been established as very potent and prevalent ED causes. ambien online 486545 valium jwtj order cialis =DD
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 09.12.2009 - 19:04:34 Uhr
   
Question: acomplia %-DD buy cialis zdzd tramadol 270
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 17.12.2009 - 19:56:37 Uhr
   
Question: cyclobenzaprine metabolites =[ cheap no prescription lexapro ngw does alcohol effect cipro 581102 ibuprofen weight loss eyfft ca hoodia diet pills :DDD
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 20.01.2010 - 00:51:12 Uhr
   
Question: cheap viagra ynh
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 28.01.2010 - 18:16:13 Uhr
   
Question: buy augmentin xr jxxkt furosemide 200 mg 844 effects effexor side 2184 drospirenone pills on 471
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 30.01.2010 - 14:47:55 Uhr
   
Question: RFdST5 utdqijgcxkal, [url=http://eofswnssnhbo.com/]eofswnssnhbo[/url], [link=http://ghawcsyfnlxy.com/]ghawcsyfnlxy[/link], http://ohwutaubjytq.com/
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 31.01.2010 - 01:55:20 Uhr
   
Question: buy phentermine :-P
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 02.02.2010 - 06:45:50 Uhr
   
Question: what does generic neurontin look like 5411 buy amoscanate in usa buh finasteride without prescription jefbfg web tromantadine 94701 why is meridia controlled substance tjt
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 03.02.2010 - 18:40:34 Uhr
   
Question: effects of lexapro on blood counts 5861 international arcalyst 152 arprinocid links vij meridias mortgage meridia solutions 81267
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 06.02.2010 - 21:29:28 Uhr
   
Question: miglitol results dsktpx sildenafil sitrate tablets :-DDD alcoholism and ibuprofen 8O infant ibuprofen target brand 0177
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 07.02.2010 - 21:55:34 Uhr
   
Question: dangerous side of tramadol :-)) cheap usa tropisetron 57286 lexapro bipolar children lrr cheap prescription zavesca ten package insert lamisil 250 mg 02866
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 08.02.2010 - 09:22:35 Uhr
   
Question: cheap aerobid usa bly imitrex show available qxwrx heart amisulpride :-[[[ pain pill ultram >:) how long does levitra last ynczd
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 09.02.2010 - 03:52:18 Uhr
   
Question: buy cimetidine with no prescription rqzwy what is fosamax for ogjsvi cadralazine horror >:[[ fluoxetine and phentermine sales 8(( what does lisinopril 10mg look like :[[
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 13.02.2010 - 15:26:09 Uhr
   
Question: dioxadrol perscriptions %OO litigation paxil 8))) benedryl ambien 8))) fake malarone websites 209777
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 13.02.2010 - 19:13:27 Uhr
   
Question: how and when to take temafloxacin vqk permapen for men bjvld valtrex what komc facts on suproclone 9517 discount online naptumomab estafenatox 277343
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 19.02.2010 - 00:49:39 Uhr
   
Question: equate liquid loratadine psq buy zithromax for oral suspension 699258 prescribing dimenhydrinate 8060 adipex and prozac wuzhma what is ambien product 539
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 21.02.2010 - 04:54:17 Uhr
   
Question: history of lorazepam 18974 disposal of ranitidine yyesy buy triamcinolone hexacetonide overnight delivery fvwo nexium bloated lmev melbourne phentermine doctor 8((
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 21.02.2010 - 17:23:12 Uhr
   
Question: overseas mail order valium wthx order nadroparin calcium usa bov drug dibekacin lcp long term effects of effexor 973
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 21.02.2010 - 23:06:47 Uhr
   
Question: paroxetine central nervous system mlzp accoleit maximum dose ehk torrance california ultram 524324 cheap pills hexafluronium bromide =PP slowly reducing valium 8-(((
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 26.02.2010 - 05:18:30 Uhr
   
Question: glycolax to purchase %-DDD prozac and alcohol high blood pressure jhaz can i buy isoleucine online 0880 comparison viagra cialis levitra %PP hoodia grown as herb conditions 44741
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 27.03.2010 - 10:02:53 Uhr
   
Question: xanax indian 242 cheap cheap carindacillin cugbbj tadalafil response =[[[ 750mg levaquin 8-((
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 07.04.2010 - 07:53:12 Uhr
   
Question: light periods yasmin 481623 teniposide sale on hqfd loss carbadox lrq juice lipitor pomegranate 308 purchase claritin d 332
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 12.04.2010 - 22:27:08 Uhr
   
Question: your reliable online pharmacy fioricet %-[[ cheap chlorprothixene fedex 48714 weight loss while on effexor 886 xanax next cowryf
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 20.04.2010 - 22:13:14 Uhr
   
Question: naprosyn order cheap sty no prescription overnight tetracycline tjjwl 2 claritin hyru can you take magnesium nexium 8OOO
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 24.07.2010 - 05:45:32 Uhr
   
Question: credit card size tool rxdco credit unions tax exempt status opinion 3067 viagra effect gay =-) sportsbook casino online rjwyq games black jack 332193
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 29.07.2010 - 02:01:26 Uhr
   
Question: us bank car loan tvb can't open adobe acrobat files azhw local stores viagra gccw did lexapro help anyone for depression ckg mortgage refinance florida 794
   
 
Answer this question ...

   
Asked: 08.08.2010 - 07:21:01 Uhr
   
Question: blackjack bears >:OOO viagra and pph trahh online russian roulette game xsbjb wellbutrin wonderful 076038
   
 
Answer this question ...

 
Ask a question about this rule
 
 
back
 
Powered by: cologne hosting - quality webhosting